Eleven tests, three sellers, one Medicare rate
We read the price of each test on the seller's own product page and set it beside the amount Medicare pays a lab for the same billing code in 2026. Medicare's rate is not a price you can buy at; it is a public yardstick for a test's going rate: CMS says it sets most lab rates from the weighted median of what private insurers pay, publishes one national number per code, and pays a separate $9.34 for drawing the blood. The last two columns are our arithmetic: the cheapest all-in price for the test bought alone (with each seller's fee), and that price divided by Medicare's rate for the test plus the draw fee.
| Test | Medicare pays (2026) | Quest | Labcorp OnDemand | Walk-In Lab | Cheapest all-in, test alone | Times Medicare's test plus draw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hemoglobin A1c | $9.71 | $35.10 + $6.00 | $39.00 | $35.00 + $6.00 | $39.00 (Labcorp OnDemand) | 2.05x |
| Lipid panel | $13.39 | $59.00 + $6.00 | $59.00 | $33.00 + $6.00 | $39.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 1.72x |
| Comprehensive metabolic panel (CMP) | $10.56 | $49.00 + $6.00 | $49.00 | $30.00 + $6.00 | $36.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 1.81x |
| Complete blood count (CBC) | $7.77 | $29.00 + $6.00 | $29.00 | $27.00 + $6.00 | $29.00 (Labcorp OnDemand) | 1.69x |
| TSH (thyroid) | $16.80 | $49.00 + $6.00 | $49.00 | $35.00 + $6.00 | $41.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 1.57x |
| Vitamin D, 25-hydroxy | $29.60 | $75.00 + $6.00 | $99.00 | $59.00 + $6.00 | $65.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 1.67x |
| PSA | $18.39 | $69.00 + $6.00 | $69.00 | $49.00 + $6.00 | $55.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 1.98x |
| Testosterone, total | $25.81 | $69.00 + $6.00 | $69.00 | $59.00 + $6.00 | $65.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 1.85x |
| Ferritin | $13.63 | Not sold alone (iron, TIBC and ferritin panel $59.00 + $6.00) | $59.00 | $29.00 + $6.00 | $35.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 1.52x |
| Vitamin B12 | $15.08 | $49.00 + $6.00 | $49.00 | $35.00 + $6.00 | $41.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 1.68x |
| hs-CRP | $12.95 | $65.00 + $6.00 | $69.00 | $45.00 + $6.00 | $51.00 (Walk-In Lab) | 2.29x |
Three patterns stand out. Walk-In Lab listed the lowest price for all 11 tests, but once fees are counted for a single test, Labcorp OnDemand is cheapest for an A1C ($39) and a CBC ($29), because its product pages show no added fee. Measured that way, the cheapest price runs from 1.52 times Medicare's rate (ferritin) to 2.29 times (hs-CRP). Quest and Labcorp list the same price for seven of the ten tests both sell alone. And vitamin D, the highest Medicare rate on this list at $29.60, is also the test the Endocrine Society's 2024 guideline suggests not ordering routinely, which we come back to below.
The cheapest way to buy the core four
Four tests are often ordered together at a yearly physical: an A1C for blood sugar, a lipid panel for cholesterol, a CMP for kidney, liver and electrolyte numbers, and a CBC for blood counts. Only the first two carry a screening recommendation (see below). Here is what the four cost bought together at each seller on November 16, 2026.
| Option | What you get | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Walk-In Lab, test by test | A1C, lipid panel, CMP, CBC | $131.00 ($121.25 with code NOV15) |
| Labcorp OnDemand, test by test | A1C, lipid panel, CMP, CBC | $176.00 |
| Labcorp OnDemand Comprehensive Health Test | The same four plus a urinalysis | $189.00 (the five bought separately: $225.00) |
| Quest, test by test | A1C (on a 10% sale), lipid panel, CMP, CBC | $178.10 |
| Quest Basic Health Profile (men's or women's) | CBC, CMP, lipid panel, urinalysis, plus a PSA (men) or a TSH (women); no A1C | $149.25 on sale from $199.00, plus $6.00 |
| What Medicare pays a lab | The four tests and one blood draw | $50.77 |
Walk-In Lab comes in $45 below Labcorp and $47.10 below Quest for the same four tests, and it is a reseller: its how-it-works page says Labcorp orders go to Labcorp and Quest orders go to Quest, so you are drawn at the same patient service centers. The bundles only pay if you want what they add. Labcorp's Comprehensive Health Test costs $13 more than the four tests bought separately and adds a urinalysis that Labcorp sells alone for $49. Quest's Basic Health Profile ($149.25 on sale) costs more than its CBC, CMP and lipid panel bought separately ($137.00), and the difference buys a urinalysis plus a PSA or TSH, not an A1C, the one test on this list with a diabetes screening recommendation behind it.
Before you pay cash, check whether it is free
If you have insurance, HealthCare.gov says Marketplace plans and many other plans must cover listed preventive services without a copayment or coinsurance, "even if you haven't met your yearly deductible," generally when the provider is in network. Two of the eleven tests can fall under that list:
- Diabetes screening (an A1C or a glucose test). The USPSTF recommends it for adults 35 to 70 who have overweight or obesity (grade B, August 2021). HealthCare.gov's list, read the same day, still says 40 to 70, the pre-2021 wording; the USPSTF lowered the starting age to 35 in its 2021 statement.
- Cholesterol screening "for adults of certain ages or at higher risk," in HealthCare.gov's words.
The CBC, CMP, TSH, vitamin D, PSA, testosterone, ferritin, B12 and hs-CRP do not appear on that list, so with a deductible you pay your plan's negotiated rate until the deductible is met. That rate can be higher or lower than a cash price, and only your plan can tell you which. Ask for it before you choose. If you pay a reseller instead, Walk-In Lab says it does not file insurance claims and will give you a receipt to file yourself, without guaranteeing reimbursement.
On Medicare, covered diagnostic lab tests usually cost you nothing, and three screenings are free on a schedule: cholesterol, lipid and triglyceride tests once every 5 years, diabetes screening up to twice a year if you have a risk factor, and a PSA once every 12 months for men over 50. If a lab hands you a notice that Medicare may not pay, read what each ABN option means before you sign. The yearly wellness visit costs nothing with a provider who accepts assignment, while Original Medicare does not pay for a routine physical; our comparison explains the difference.
Four things that change the price you pay
- Fees. Quest shows "+ $6.00 Physician Service Fee" beside the price of every test in our table; Walk-In Lab shows "+$6.00 per order physician fee"; Labcorp OnDemand's product pages show none. Either way a clinician orders every test: Labcorp says all OnDemand testing "requires an order from an authorized healthcare professional."
- Sales and codes. On November 16, Quest had its A1C at 10% off ($35.10 from $39.00), Labcorp ran 25% off orders of $250 or more with code SAVE25 (subscriptions excluded), and Walk-In Lab had code NOV15 through November 30. Sale prices move, so read the price on the day you buy.
- Where you live. Quest's pages say collection is not available in Arizona, Hawaii or Puerto Rico. Walk-In Lab says it cannot sell Labcorp orders in New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Massachusetts or Maryland, or Quest orders in New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island or Arizona.
- Where the blood is drawn. Quest charges an additional $99 for an in-home draw where it offers one.
If you pay cash, you have a right to an estimate
Under the federal No Surprises rules, CMS says that if you are not using insurance, your provider must give you a good faith estimate of expected charges if you ask, or if you schedule care at least 3 business days ahead. If the bill comes in at least $400 above the estimate, CMS says you may be able to dispute it. That matters most when a clinic or hospital lab draws the blood, because their cash prices are not posted on a product page the way Quest's and Labcorp's are. Both Quest and Labcorp also say they accept HSA and FSA cards.
Which of these are worth buying
Price is the second question. The first is whether a test will change anything you do. Our guide to the blood tests worth getting every year goes through the evidence; in short, the A1C and lipid panel carry screening recommendations, a CMP and CBC are usually ordered to look for something specific, and three tests on this list come with caveats you should know before paying:
- Vitamin D: the Endocrine Society's 2024 guideline suggests against routine testing without an established reason, and the USPSTF calls the evidence for screening insufficient.
- PSA: the USPSTF grades screening C for men 55 to 69 (an individual decision) and D from 70, so talk the decision through before you buy one.
- Testosterone: the Endocrine Society's guideline confirms a low result with a second fasting morning test, so a diagnosis costs two tests, not one.
When a direct-to-consumer test is the wrong route
Buy through your own clinician instead if you have symptoms, if you are being treated for the condition the test measures, or if you are pregnant. Results from these sites go to you and to an independent clinician the company contracts, who may discuss your results (Quest's TSH page says that clinician may prescribe treatment for an underactive thyroid) but who does not have your history. If you feel acutely unwell, skip the test. Chest pain, severe shortness of breath, fainting or vomiting blood: call 911. Black or bloody stool or other new, severe symptoms: get care the same day. Do not order a test online and wait.
What we checked and what we did not
We read every price on the seller's own product page on November 16, 2026, and every Medicare rate in CMS's October 2026 fee schedule file. We did not check out at any seller, so we could not confirm whether Quest's $6.00 fee is charged once per order or per test, or whether Labcorp adds anything at checkout. We did not read insurers' negotiated rates or hospitals' posted cash prices for these codes, and we did not compare prices at Walk-In Lab after choosing a lab at checkout. We re-read these prices every month; promotion codes, such as the one ending November 30, come off the page when they expire.
Every price, Medicare rate and coverage rule on this page was checked against the pages listed under Sources on November 16, 2026. We did not buy or take any of these tests.
Frequently asked questions
How much is blood work without insurance?
For four tests often ordered together at a yearly physical (A1C, lipid panel, CMP and CBC), we found $131 at Walk-In Lab, $176 at Labcorp OnDemand and $178.10 at Quest on November 16, 2026, including each seller's listed fees. A single common test bought alone runs $29 (a CBC at Labcorp OnDemand) to $99 (vitamin D at Labcorp OnDemand), fees included.
Is Quest or Labcorp cheaper?
For the ten tests both sell alone, they listed the same price for seven on November 16, 2026. Quest's listed price was lower for the A1C (on a sale), vitamin D and hs-CRP, but Quest adds a $6.00 physician service fee that Labcorp's product pages do not show, and after that fee only vitamin D stays cheaper at Quest.
Why is a lab test so much cheaper for Medicare?
Medicare sets one national payment per billing code. For the core four plus one blood draw it pays $50.77. CMS sets most of those rates from the weighted median of what private insurers pay, so it is a negotiated price, not a retail one; the cheapest prices we found for a test bought alone, fees included, were 1.52 to 2.29 times Medicare's rate for the test and draw.
Can I use my HSA or FSA?
Quest's and Labcorp OnDemand's product pages both say HSA and FSA cards are accepted.
Will a cash lab test count toward my deductible?
Only your plan can answer that. Walk-In Lab says it does not file claims and will give you a receipt to submit yourself, without guaranteeing reimbursement. Ask your plan before you pay.