How pages are checked
Medical review
Pages on this site are checked against the documents that set their numbers: the guideline, the drug label, the study, the public record. No named clinician reviews the site yet, and we say so rather than invent one. This page sets out what the checks are, with real cases, and what they cannot do.
What review means here today
Documentary review. Clinical claims are tied to a guideline, label, public record or peer-reviewed study, and the source's title and text are read against the claim it supports. Until an editorial or clinical review of a guide is logged, it is the only kind of review that guide claims. Each guide carries the byline of the editor who edited it, and none of our editors is a clinician.
Going forward, guides also get an editorial review from our Senior Health Editor, Sarah Whitcomb, and clinical review is coordinated by our Medical Review Coordinator, Rebecca Hayes, who assigns guides that need it to qualified healthcare professionals. A guide shows each review once it has happened, with the reviewer's name and the date. How guides are reviewed sets out both steps.
The checks, step by step
- Find the document that sets the number. That means the body that decides it: the FDA label, the guideline, the agency's own page, the published trial, the seller's own price page. A news story or another health site can point us to a source. It is never the source.
- Read the title and the sentence, not just the link. A link that opens proves only that a page exists. For a study we read its PubMed record and check that the paper is about the claim it is cited for.
- Print the date. Each reference range and screening row carries its source's own date. Each price carries the day we read it. A number that was right in 2023 can be wrong today, and the date lets you see which you are looking at.
- Let the software refuse what fails. A biomarker range cannot be loaded without a source link, a date and a bound. A supplement table will not build if a product's listed amounts do not match its label record in the NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database. A partner's link cannot appear on any page until a dated check of the FDA warning-letter record is on file.
- Say when we could not check. If a source cannot be opened or read, the number comes off the page or the page says it was not checked. We do not fill the gap from memory.
- Fix it in public. When a page was wrong while readers could see it, the fix goes in the corrections log with the date, the page and what it says now.
What that has looked like
A claim we could not trace (November 3, 2026). Our magnesium evidence guide said two later, larger studies found magnesium oxide absorbed best. When we went back to cite them, we could not find them, and the studies we did find in PubMed say something different. The guide now describes those studies and cites them, and the correction is in the log.
A source we could not open (October 28, 2026). Two pages gave an "optimal" fasting triglyceride of under 100 mg/dL from a 2011 American Heart Association statement. We could not get the statement's text to check its wording, so the figure was removed from both pages. A number we cannot check is not printed.
An offer readers could not get (September 4, 2026). A 30% BetterHelp discount was copied correctly from the ad network's listing, and readers still could not have it: the link led to an offer for members of an honor society. Since then we load each link and read the page a reader lands on before we quote a discount.
A record we could not open (November 3, 2026). USP's product lookup would not load for us, so the supplement tables say "Not checked" in the USP column instead of guessing. NIH's fact-sheet pages would not load either, so we read them from dated Internet Archive copies and print the date of the copy.
What this review cannot do
It cannot tell you whether a test, a dose or a product is right for you. It does not weigh your history, your other medicines or your results, which is what a clinician who knows you does. It is not a clinical review and we do not call it one. Read every page here as an account of what the sources say, and take the decision to someone who can examine you.
Who reviews pages today
No named clinician reviews this site yet. Guides are researched and drafted with AI assistance, then edited by the editor named on each guide. None of our editors is a clinician. The documentary checks described above are how pages are prepared; a named review appears on a guide only once it is logged, with its date.
Going forward, guides also get an editorial review from our Senior Health Editor, Sarah Whitcomb, and clinical review is coordinated by our Medical Review Coordinator, Rebecca Hayes, who assigns guides that need it to qualified healthcare professionals. Neither is credited on a guide until that review is logged, with the date.
The clinical step is a real limit until a clinician joins, and we treat it as one. A page claims a clinician read it only when a licensed clinician's review of that page is logged with their credential, license and the date; the structured data names the guide's editor as the author, typed as a person with their real title and no clinical credential, and names a medical reviewer only from that log. The words "medically reviewed" appear on a guide only when that review is logged.
When a licensed clinician joins, this section becomes the roster: name, credentials, license state, the pages reviewed and the date of each review, each verifiable against the state licensing board. Nothing is listed here until it can be verified that way.
How a guide moves through review
Every guide is in one of these states. Apart from Draft and Published, each comes from a dated record, not from a setting on the page. Today, of 113 guides, 0 are medically reviewed, 3 are marked as needing a clinician, 10 are waiting for one, and 2 need an update.
- Published
- Live, with no open review item. It shows a review credit only if one is logged, with its date.
- Draft
- Written and not published.
- Editorial review
- An editor checks each claim against its source, the citations, the readability and these standards. A guide shows "Fact-checked by" an editor only after that check is logged, with its date.
- Medical review required
- The guide makes claims a clinician should read: about medicines, treatment, doses or symptoms that mean getting care now.
- Awaiting medical review
- The guide is waiting for a licensed clinician in the right field.
- Medically reviewed
- A licensed clinician's review of this exact text is logged with their name, credential, license and the date. Only then does the guide say "Medically reviewed".
- Update required
- The guide's text changed after its review, or a source it quotes was replaced. A review credit comes off the page as soon as the reviewed text changes, until the new text is reviewed. When a source was replaced, the page says so at the top, with the date.
What a medical review means, and what it does not
A medical review means a licensed clinician read the guide's clinical claims and approved them on the date shown. It does not mean the clinician wrote the guide, endorses a product or service on the page, or knows your situation. An editorial review, which checks claims against their sources, is not a medical review, and we never label one as the other.
How to apply
If you are a licensed clinician (MD, DO, NP, PA, PharmD or RD) and would like to review pages in your area, write to us. Reviewers are credited by name and license on the pages they review, with the review date.
The link selects the Medical review topic. Include your name, credentials, license state and the areas you would review.