How we work
How we verify
Readers act on the numbers here, so nothing numeric ships unverified. These are the rules, in the order we apply them.
Last updated:
No anonymous medicine.
Clinical claims on this site trace to named primary sources. A page names a reviewer only when a named clinician has reviewed it. Every guide carries the byline of the editor who edited it, linked to their profile, and none of our editors is a clinician. If a piece is wrong, tell us through the contact form.
1. Primary source or nothing
Primary means the entity that sets the number: the FDA label, the guideline document, the agency's fee schedule, the manufacturer's own price page, the peer-reviewed paper. Trackers, aggregators, news reports and other publishers are useful for finding a primary source and are never cited for a number. If the only source is an aggregator, the number is marked unverified or cut.
2. Every figure carries its source's own date
A price, a threshold or a recommendation can be correct as published and wrong today. Reference-range rows and screening rows print the source's effective date; prices on reviews are printed as of the date we read them; guides state when they were last checked.
3. We read the title, not just the link
A citation is verified only when someone has read the source's title and text against the specific claim it supports. A link that resolves proves only that the page exists. We re-probe every external link before publishing and again when a page is updated; a dead citation is removed rather than left.
4. Ranges are ledgers, not averages
Laboratories print different reference intervals and guideline bodies set different targets. Rather than blend them into one number, the Biomarker Library shows each as its own row with its own source: a lab interval is labeled as a lab interval, a treatment threshold as a threshold, and where a guideline target differs from a lab's normal range we say so.
5. Our own data is not ground truth
A count or a rate derived from our own database is published only after we have measured how complete that database is. A gap in our records reads exactly like a gap in the world, so we do not present one as the other.
6. Partners are checked before they appear
Before a product or service can be linked, we run it against FDA warning letters and import alerts, state board and attorney-general actions where the operating entity is named, and, for sellers of compounded medicines, their own disclosure that the products are not FDA-approved. The date of the check is recorded and published on how we pick. A partner without a recorded check cannot render a link; the software enforces it.
7. Uncertainty is published, not hidden
"Unverified", "the publisher gives no total" and "we could not source this" are all acceptable on this site and all better than a confident wrong number. Where we compute a figure rather than read it, we label it as our arithmetic and show the components.
8. Every review is logged, with a name and a date
Going forward, each guide gets an editorial review from our Senior Health Editor, and a guide that needs it gets a clinical review from a qualified healthcare professional, coordinated by our Medical Review Coordinator. Each review is logged with the reviewer's name and the date, and the guide shows it once it has happened. A review line stays only while the guide's words are the ones that were reviewed. Any new, removed or changed word or number takes it off until the new text is reviewed. Adding, removing or changing a link to another of our pages, with no word changed, does not. A guide is described as medically reviewed only when a licensed clinician's review of it is logged, with a credential and a license a reader can check. The software will not print a reviewer's name from anything but that log. How guides are reviewed sets out both steps. No licensed clinician has reviewed a guide yet; until one is logged, a guide says so on its review line.
9. Software helps; people decide
Guides are researched and drafted with AI assistance, then edited by the editor named on the guide. Who reviewed a guide for accuracy, and when, appears on it once that review is logged. Software also runs many of the checks above: it refuses a reference range with no source or date and a partner link with no dated FDA check. Software does not decide what a page tells you about your health.
The eight questions we ask before publishing a dataset-backed claim
- Can I point at the sentence that says this?
- Is this the whole thing, or one line of it?
- Does the publisher actually publish the aggregate I want, or am I manufacturing it?
- Was this ever operative, or is it a plan?
- Does "covered" mean paid for the thing the reader thinks?
- Has the scheme changed, not just the amount?
- Is there a single value, or must I name a tier?
- Does my provenance label certify the specific claim, or merely that the document exists?
Found an error in something we published?
Use the contact form and give us the page URL, the claim in question, and any supporting documentation. We acknowledge every correction request within five business days. Confirmed material corrections are listed with the date and what changed in our corrections log.