The three options on the current form
| Option | What happens | Can you appeal? | When it can fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | You get the test; the provider bills Medicare and you receive a Medicare Summary Notice. You may be asked to pay now; if Medicare pays, you are refunded, minus copays or deductibles | Yes, using the directions on the Medicare Summary Notice | You think the test may be covered, or you want an official answer |
| 2 | You get the test and Medicare is not billed; you pay | No, because no claim exists | You are sure it is not covered and want no claim filed |
| 3 | You do not get the test and owe nothing | No | The test can wait until it is covered, or a better test exists |
CMS's instructions require you to choose one option yourself: "Pre-selection of an option by the notifier invalidates the notice." If you get Medicare and Medicaid together, the instructions say you must be told to check Option 1, and the provider cannot bill you until both programs have decided the claim.
The rules that most often trigger a notice for blood work
CMS lets providers give a notice routinely only in a few cases, and frequency limits are one: when Medicare "has established a frequency limit for any item or service, a routine written notice can be given," stating the limit as the reason. These are the limits that apply to common blood tests.
| Test | The limit | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Cholesterol screening | Once every 5 years, counted as 59 full months after the month of the last one | 42 CFR 410.17 |
| Lipid monitoring on treatment | Yearly panel; one part up to six times in the first year | NCD 190.23 |
| Diabetes screening (glucose or A1C) | Two tests within 12 months of the most recent screening | 42 CFR 410.18 |
| A1C with controlled diabetes | Not more often than every three months | NCD 190.21 |
| Thyroid tests, stable patient | Up to two times a year | NCD 190.22 |
| Screening PSA | Once 11 full months have passed since the month of the last one | 42 CFR 410.39 |
| PSA for urinary symptoms | Generally once a year unless the condition changes | NCD 190.31 |
| Vitamin D | Set by region; for example, up to three a year at First Coast and Novitas | Local coverage determinations |
The other trigger is the reason on the order. Codes like Z13.6 are the reason written on the order; five-digit codes like 80061 name the test. The national lab rules list the diagnoses that support each test, and a test ordered with a reason that is not listed, such as a thyroid test at a routine physical or a vitamin D test for fatigue, is one Medicare is expected to deny. CMS's sample lab notice puts cholesterol, ferritin and iron under "Medicare does not pay for these tests for your condition," and the A1C, Pap test and screening PSA under "Medicare does not pay for these tests as often as ordered for you." The third reason, "Medicare does not pay for experimental or research use tests," covers what CMS's manual calls "Research Use Only" and "Investigational Use Only" laboratory tests.
What makes a notice valid, and what if it is not
- Before the test. The notice must be delivered before the service, "far enough in advance" for you to consider your options. A notice handed over after your blood is drawn cannot shift the cost to you.
- Specific. It must name the test and a real reason. CMS says simply stating "medically unnecessary" or the equivalent is not an acceptable reason.
- An estimate. Providers must make "a good faith effort to insert a reasonable estimate" of the cost.
- Not routine. Notices handed to every patient "where there is no specific, identifiable reason to believe Medicare will not pay" are not valid, except for frequency limits like those above. A notice signed blank and filled in later is invalid.
- Explained. The provider must answer your questions; CMS treats a refusal to answer as defective delivery. You can ask for a copy, and should keep one.
If a required notice was not given, or was given improperly, you are generally not liable: CMS's manual says such a beneficiary "is relieved from liability," and a provider that collected must make "prompt refunds." The word generally matters. Under 42 CFR 411.404, a written notice counts if it was given by the provider, the contractor or a review committee, and "A notice concerning similar or reasonably comparable services furnished on a previous occasion also meets this criterion." When you did not know and the provider did, 42 CFR 411.402 lets Medicare repay you and recover the money from the provider. Medicare.gov puts the basic point for patients: an ABN "isn't an official denial of coverage by Medicare."
If you chose Option 1 and Medicare says no
The decision arrives on your Medicare Summary Notice. You can ask for a redetermination, the first level of appeal, "within 120 calendar days from the date a party receives the notice of the initial determination," and Medicare presumes you received it 5 days after the date on the notice. Include your clinician's note on why the test was needed. A frequency denial for a test that was really diagnostic, and documented as diagnostic at the visit, such as a repeat PSA after a high result, is the kind of case an appeal can fix; changing codes after the fact is not.
When there is no notice at all
Some care is never covered, such as a routine physical exam. For that, CMS says the notice is optional, a courtesy; when it is used that way, "the patient doesn't need to choose an option box or sign the notice." And on Medicare Advantage, CMS's manual says the ABN "is not used"; instead you, or your clinician, can ask the plan for an organization determination, its decision on whether it will pay, before the service (42 CFR 422.566).
Before you sign
- What exactly is not expected to be covered, and why? Ask which rule or diagnosis is the problem.
- Is there a reason on my record that is covered? Tell the clinician about symptoms or conditions you really have; never ask for a diagnosis that is not true.
- When would it be covered? For a frequency limit, the eligible month may be close.
- What is the estimated cost, and is that the full price? Medicare's 2026 rates are a yardstick: $13.39 for a lipid panel, $9.71 for an A1C, $16.80 for a TSH, $29.60 for vitamin D.
- Who will bill me, the office or the lab? CMS lets either one be the notifier when a clinician draws blood and a lab runs it.
If you decide to pay out of pocket, compare first: our blood test price comparison sets direct-to-consumer prices beside Medicare's rates.
In an emergency, get care first: CMS says ABNs "are never required in emergency situations."
What we checked and what we did not
We read form CMS-R-131 and its instructions, CMS's sample lab notice, its ABN page, chapter 30, section 50 of the claims manual, Medicare.gov's protections page, 42 CFR 405.942, 411.402, 411.404 and 422.566 on eCFR, and the frequency rules in the table at their sources, all on November 16, 2026. We did not test how any lab fills in its estimates, and we did not read any Medicare Advantage plan's prior-authorization rules for lab tests.
Every Medicare rate, coverage rule and notice requirement on this page was checked against the pages listed under Sources on November 16, 2026.
Frequently asked questions
What does a Medicare ABN mean for a lab test?
The lab or clinician expects Original Medicare not to pay for a test, often because of your diagnosis or how often it has been done. If you sign and choose the test, you may have to pay the lab's usual fee.
Which ABN option should I choose?
Option 1 if you want the test and want Medicare to decide, since it keeps your right to appeal. Option 2 only if you want the test and no claim filed. Option 3 if you do not want the test.
Do I have to pay if I was not given an ABN?
Generally no, when a notice was required. CMS says a patient who did not receive proper notice is relieved from liability, and the provider must refund what it collected. An earlier written notice about similar services can count against you (42 CFR 411.404).
Is an ABN a denial from Medicare?
No. Medicare.gov says it isn't an official denial of coverage. Medicare decides when the claim is filed under Option 1.
How long do I have to appeal after an ABN?
120 calendar days from when you receive the Medicare Summary Notice with the decision; Medicare presumes you received it 5 days after its date.